In the realm of deep learning, particularly for handling sequential data like text, audio, or time series, several fundamental architectures have emerged as dominant paradigms. This tutorial will demystify three key categories: Autoencoding Models (Encoder-Only), Autoregressive Models (Decoder-Only), and Sequence-to-Sequence Models (Encoder-Decoder). We’ll explore their core concepts, typical applications, and how they differ.
1. The Foundation: Transformers
Before diving into the specific architectures, it’s crucial to understand that many modern implementations of these models are built upon the Transformer architecture. Introduced in the “Attention Is All You Need” paper (Vaswani et al., 2017), Transformers revolutionized sequence modeling by replacing recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and convolutional neural networks (CNNs) with a mechanism called self-attention.
Key Advantages of Transformers
- Parallelization: Unlike RNNs, which process sequences step-by-step, Transformers can process all tokens in a sequence simultaneously, significantly speeding up training.
- Long-range Dependencies: Self-attention allows the model to weigh the importance of all other tokens in a sequence when processing a single token, effectively capturing long-range dependencies more efficiently than RNNs.
- Scalability: Transformers scale well with larger datasets and model sizes, leading to the development of incredibly powerful Large Language Models (LLMs).
While we’ll discuss the architectural categories, keep in mind that the internal mechanics often leverage Transformer blocks (made of multi-head self-attention and feed-forward layers).
2. Autoencoding Models: Encoder-Only Architectures
Core Concept
Autoencoding models, particularly those that are “Encoder-Only,” are designed to learn rich, contextualized representations (embeddings) of input data. Their primary goal is to understand the input by reconstructing it or by predicting masked parts of it. They are typically trained using a “denoising” or “masked language modeling” objective, where parts of the input are intentionally corrupted (e.g., masked), and the model learns to predict the original, uncorrupted input.
Architecture
An Encoder-Only model consists solely of an Encoder stack. This encoder takes an input sequence and processes it through multiple layers of self-attention and feed-forward networks. The output is a high-dimensional vector representation for each token in the input sequence, capturing its meaning in context with all other tokens.
- Input: A sequence of tokens (e.g., words in a sentence).
- Encoder Stack: Multiple identical layers, each containing:
- Multi-Head Self-Attention: Allows each token to “attend” to all other tokens in the input sequence to compute a context-aware representation.
- Feed-Forward Network: Applies non-linear transformations to the attention output.
- Residual Connections and Layer Normalization: Facilitate stable training of deep networks.
- Output: A sequence of contextualized embeddings (vectors), one for each input token. These embeddings represent the model’s “understanding” of the input.
Training Objective (Example: Masked Language Modeling – MLM)
During training, a percentage of tokens in the input sequence are randomly replaced with a special “[MASK]” token. The model’s task is to predict the original, masked tokens based on the surrounding context. This forces the model to learn deep bidirectional relationships within the text.
Key Characteristics
- Bidirectional Context: Can access information from both left (past) and right (future) contexts of a token. This is crucial for understanding the full meaning of a word in a sentence.
- Representation Learning: Excellent at generating high-quality, dense vector representations of text.
- Non-Generative (Directly): These models are not designed to generate new sequences from scratch in an autoregressive manner. Their output is typically a transformation or prediction related to the input.
Popular Examples
- BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers): The pioneering Encoder-Only model. Trained on Masked Language Modeling and Next Sentence Prediction tasks.
- RoBERTa: An optimized version of BERT with more training data and a few architectural tweaks.
- DistilBERT, ALBERT, ELECTRA: Variants of BERT focusing on efficiency or different training objectives.
Typical Applications
- Text Classification: Sentiment analysis, spam detection, topic classification.
- Named Entity Recognition (NER): Identifying entities like names, locations, organizations.
- Question Answering (Extractive): Finding the answer within a given text (e.g., SQuAD dataset).
- Text Similarity/Semantic Search: Finding documents or sentences with similar meanings.
- Feature Extraction: Generating embeddings for downstream tasks.
Analogy
Think of an Encoder-Only model as a highly skilled linguistic analyst. It reads a text, thoroughly understands every word in its context (even if some words are missing, it can infer them), and then produces a rich, nuanced summary (the embeddings) of the entire piece, but it doesn’t write new content from scratch.
3. Autoregressive Models: Decoder-Only Architectures
Core Concept
Autoregressive models, or “Decoder-Only” models, are designed for sequential generation. They predict the next token in a sequence based on all the previously generated tokens. This means their generation process is inherently unidirectional, moving from left to right (or in the order of the sequence).
Architecture
A Decoder-Only model consists solely of a Decoder stack, often very similar to the decoder part of a full Encoder-Decoder Transformer but without the cross-attention mechanism that would link it to an encoder’s output.
- Input: A “start-of-sequence” token, and then sequentially, the previously generated tokens.
- Decoder Stack: Multiple identical layers, each containing:
- Masked Multi-Head Self-Attention: Crucially, this attention mechanism is masked. It ensures that when predicting the next token, the model can only attend to previous tokens in the sequence, not future ones. This prevents “cheating” by looking ahead.
- Feed-Forward Network: Applies non-linear transformations.
- Residual Connections and Layer Normalization.
- Output Layer (Softmax): Converts the final hidden state into a probability distribution over the entire vocabulary for the next token.
Training Objective
Trained using a standard language modeling objective: predict the next token given all preceding tokens in a sequence. This is done by maximizing the likelihood of the training data.
Key Characteristics
- Unidirectional Context: Can only attend to past (left) tokens. This is a fundamental constraint for autoregressive generation.
- Generative: Excellently suited for generating new, coherent sequences from a given prompt.
- Probabilistic: Learns a probability distribution over the next token.
Popular Examples
- GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) series (GPT-2, GPT-3, GPT-4, etc.): The most well-known examples of Decoder-Only models, powerful in text generation.
- Chinchilla, LLaMA, PaLM: Other prominent large language models built on the Decoder-Only architecture.
- Bloom: An open-source large language model.
Typical Applications
- Text Generation: Creative writing, story generation, poetry, code generation.
- Chatbots/Conversational AI: Generating human-like responses in dialogues.
- Summarization (Abstractive): Creating new summaries that might not directly copy phrases from the original text.
- Translation (less common directly, but can be prompted for it): Though Encoder-Decoder is more common.
- Code Completion: Predicting the next line or block of code.
Analogy
Imagine a skilled orator or storyteller. Given an opening line, they can organically and coherently extend the narrative, always building upon what they’ve just said, without knowing how the story will end until they tell it. They focus on the flow and progression of the narrative.
4. Sequence-to-Sequence Models: Encoder-Decoder Architectures
Core Concept
Sequence-to-Sequence (Seq2Seq) models are designed for tasks where an input sequence is transformed into a different output sequence. They are a combination of an encoder and a decoder, working in tandem. The encoder reads the entire input sequence and compresses its meaning into a fixed-size “context vector” or a set of “contextualized representations,” which the decoder then uses to generate the output sequence.
Architecture
A Seq2Seq Transformer model consists of two main parts: an Encoder stack and a Decoder stack.
- Encoder Stack:
- Identical to the Encoder-Only architecture.
- Takes the entire input sequence.
- Processes it using multi-head self-attention.
- Outputs a set of contextualized representations (or “key-value” pairs) for each input token. This output is then passed to the decoder.
- Decoder Stack:
- Similar to the Decoder-Only architecture, but with an additional cross-attention (or encoder-decoder attention) layer.
- Masked Multi-Head Self-Attention: Attends only to previously generated tokens in the output sequence.
- Multi-Head Cross-Attention: This is the crucial part. It allows each token in the decoder’s input to attend to all tokens in the encoder’s output. This mechanism enables the decoder to leverage the contextual understanding of the input sequence captured by the encoder.
- Feed-Forward Network.
- Output Layer (Softmax): Predicts the next token in the output sequence.
Training Objective
Trained to maximize the likelihood of mapping an input sequence to a target output sequence.
Key Characteristics
- Input-Output Mapping: Specifically designed for tasks that involve transforming one sequence into another.
- Encoder’s Bidirectionality, Decoder’s Unidirectionality: The encoder can use full bidirectional context of the input, while the decoder generates autoregressively, only looking at past generated tokens and the full encoded input.
- Strong for Conditional Generation: Excellent at generating an output sequence conditioned on a specific input sequence.
Popular Examples
- T5 (Text-to-Text Transfer Transformer): Frames almost all NLP tasks as a text-to-text problem (e.g., “translate English to German: …”, “summarize: …”).
- BART (Bidirectional and Auto-Regressive Transformers): Uses a BERT-like encoder (bidirectional) and a GPT-like decoder (autoregressive) for denoising pre-training.
- NMT (Neural Machine Translation) models: Many state-of-the-art translation systems use this architecture.
- ProphetNet: A Seq2Seq model for multi-granularity prediction.
Typical Applications
- Machine Translation: Translating text from one language to another.
- Summarization (Abstractive): Generating summaries based on an input document.
- Dialogue Systems (Response Generation): Generating responses in a conversation based on the dialogue history.
- Question Answering (Generative): Generating an answer to a question (not just extracting it).
- Text Simplification: Rewriting complex text into simpler language.
- Data-to-Text Generation: Generating natural language descriptions from structured data.
Analogy
Consider a skilled interpreter or translator. They first meticulously listen to and understand the entire original message (Encoder). Once they have grasped its full meaning, they then start speaking or writing the translated message, carefully constructing each part while constantly referring back to their understanding of the original (Decoder with cross-attention).
5. Conclusion
Understanding these three fundamental deep learning architectures—Encoder-Only, Decoder-Only, and Encoder-Decoder—is essential for anyone working with modern NLP and sequence modeling. Each architecture is optimized for different types of tasks, leveraging the power of the Transformer’s self-attention mechanism in distinct ways. By choosing the right architecture, you can efficiently tackle a vast array of problems, from understanding text meaning to generating highly coherent and creative content.